1 July 2011

The Dutch Parliament has voted to make stunning animals prior to slaughter obligatory in the Netherlands, including religious slaughter.

Animal welfare groups have welcomed the move, which they say represents a step forward. An end to the exemption for religious slaughter, where animals are killed fully conscious without stunning, will alleviate the suffering of up to one million animals in the Netherlands, according to Eurogroup for Animals.

The Bill, which received overwhelming support in the Dutch Parliament (116 out of 150 votes), is based on the strong scientific consensus that animals rendered unconscious prior to slaughter suffer less than animals bled while fully conscious.

Dr Michel Courat, Policy Officer for Farm Animals at Eurogroup for Animals, who welcomed the move, commented, "This is a major step forward for animal welfare and we urge all of the 26 other European Union member states to follow the example of the Dutch government. It will however be possible for religious groups to get an exemption, but only when they provide indisputably proof that their alternative method will not cause more harm to animal welfare than pre-slaughter stunning."

He continued, "It is a disgrace that consumers are buying meat from animals that have been slaughtered in this way without their knowledge and against their wishes. The Dutch have now sent a very clear signal and the European Commission must act to ensure that in future this is the standard across the European Union."

The Dutch Parlaiment has insisted the ban is not directed against religious slaughter as such, but states that religion is not a sufficient reason to let animals suffer unnecessarily. As such, parliamentarians claim the ruling is “an invitation to religious groups to explore the boundaries of what their faiths allows and to implement new, innovative animal welfare friendly methods.”

Dr Courat said the group has been monitoring the number of animals slaughtered without prior stunning in the EU and is, “very concerned that the amount of meat coming from animals slaughtered in this way is much higher than the amount required to meet the needs of the religious communities in the EU.”